Similarities and Divergences in Attitudes Toward Georgian Irish Heritage


Dissonant heritage

How to Cite

Belgacem, S. (2022). Similarities and Divergences in Attitudes Toward Georgian Irish Heritage. Journal of Traditional Building, Architecture and Urbanism, (3), 396–405.


This paper makes a comparative analysis of the treatment of Georgian heritage in Northern Ireland (NI) and the Republic of Ireland (Éire). It assesses this treatment through a review of listing practices, lost houses, and the parallel evolution of planning policies along with the historical reasons for this, analyzing the nature of the drivers of and limits to the conservation of the Georgian buildings of Ireland. NI and Éire share most of the factors that led in the early twentieth century to significant heritage loss, and later to the creation of effective and inclusive conservation legislation. Our study shows that the political mindset in Éire is what has most discouraged listing and conservation, along with a lack of key legislation as passed in Great Britain but not in Ireland prior to partition, due to the political context.


An Taisce. 2022. What we do. (consulted on 15/04/2022).

Ashworth, Gregory John; and Tunbridge, John. 1996. Dissonant Heritage: the management of the past as a resource in conflict. Chichester and New York: Wiley.

Belfast Telegraph. 2016. “Outrage” at weekend demolition of historic Belfast buildings in North Street. (consulted on 15/04/2022).

British and Irish Stately Homes. 2022. Lost Ireland. (consulted on 15/04/2022).

Glin, Desmond Fitzgerald; Griffin, David; and Robinson, Nicholas. 1988. Vanishing country houses of Ireland. Dublin: Irish Architectural Archive and the Irish Georgian Society.

Fry, Malcolm. 2003. Preserving Ancient and Historic Monuments and Sites in State Care in Northern Ireland, c1921 to c1955. Part One: Establishing a System of Care. Ulster Journal of Archaeology, 62: 161–175, doi:10.2307/20568324.

Fry, Malcolm. 2005. Preserving Ancient and Historic Monuments and Sites in State Care in Northern Ireland, c 1921 to c 1955. Part Two: Developing a System of Care. Ulster Journal of Archaeology, 64: 160–171, doi:10.2307/20568360.

Historic England. 2022. Timeline of Conservation Catalysts and Legislation. (consulted on 15/04/2022).

McClelland, Andrew. 2017. Inventorying Armagh: Max Lock, civil society, and the diffusion of planning ideas into Northern Ireland in the 1960s. Planning Perspectives, 32, 3: 401–423, doi:10.1080/02665433.2016.1277953.

Negussie, Elene. 2001. Dublin, Ireland. In Pickard, Rob (ed.), Management of Historic Centers, 133–161. London and New York: Spon Press.

Negussie, Elene. 2003. The Evolution of Urban Conservation in Ireland: Evidence from Dublin City. Journal of Irish Urban Studies, vol. 2, 2: 15–35.

Negussie, Elene. 2006. Implications of Neoliberalism for Built Heritage Management: Institutional and Ownership Structures in Ireland and Sweden. Urban Studies, vol. 43, 10: doi:1803-1824, 10.1080/00420980600838168.

Parkinson, Arthur; Scott, Mark; and Redmond, Declan. 2015. Negotiating postcolonial legacies: shifting conservation narratives and residual colonial-built heritage in Ireland. Town Planning Review, vol. 86, 2: 203–228, doi:10.3828/tpr.2015.13.

Ryan, James. Dail debates, vol. 205, 3. (consulted on 15/04/2022).

Sengupta, Indra. 2018. Preservation between empire, nation and nationalisms: the problem of history and heritage in India. Nations and Nationalisms, 24, 1: 110–130, doi: 10.1111/nana.12376.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.


Download data is not yet available.